Using PDF for Help files

This post was inspired by new AcrobatUsers.com member GloriaMc, who wrote a very nice comment on an earlier post regarding the Acrobat Help file.

Using PDF for a help system is a great idea - providing you don’t make some basic mistakes, keep true to what PDF is, and don’t force it to be what it isn’t.

Some general rules for implementing Help documentation in PDF format might go like this:

1) RESPECT THE PRINTED PAGE, aka, think about what happens if the user prints the document.  This means, always plan the page-size for the occasion. US Letter?  A4?  Will they need page or section numbers?  Maybe you prefer landscape viewing on-screen?  Maybe you want to provide BOTH screen-optimized AND print-optimized documentation?

What you DON’T do in PDF is ignore page-size.  A PDF is a page-oriented thing.  Work with that, and you’ll be happy.

2) Consider how the documentation will be used, and where. If you anticipate largely on-screen use, then layout the documentation in a screen-friendly landscape model, and use screen-friendly (and tested) font selections, sizes and styles, based on exactly how your document will display.  You’ll want to consider whether you want the toolbars or even menu bars to display on your document.  By hiding the toolbars and providing your own customized navigation tools, you can help users “dig into” your content and get what they need far faster than with the “generic” Reader interface.

If you anticipate (or prefer to suggest) that users should print the documentation, or relevant subsections thereof, then clearly you’ll want to use printed-page friendly layouts. When you do this, consider whether you need to accommodate users from different countries. The European A4 page-size standard is longer but narrower than the 8.5″ x 11″ of US Letter standard. It’s safest to presume A4 “slimness” and US-Letter page-lengths… assuming that you don’t intend to support both page sizes independently!

On the other hand, you might want to include layouts for BOTH onscreen and printed applications, or design in a way that accommodates both in the same design. Either way, it’s worth some thought.  If you decide to develop separate screen and print-oriented layouts, know that you can easily combine them in a single PDF document, and provide a way for users to BOTH read the Help file online AND simply click a button to be offered a print-formatted version of the current section. Pretty cool!

3) ALWAYS bookmark the PDF down to the lowest practical organizational level in the file. Your Word file must be fully and carefully structured - and you must also be a little lucky - in order for Adobe Acrobat’s Convert to Adobe PDF macro to work perfectly, especially on larger or more complex documents. Failing that, there are excellent 3rd party tools such as ARTS’ Aerialist Professional, ISI’s Compose and others for adding highly structured bookmarks to PDF documents.

I cannot emphasize this point enough. There are far, FAR too many PDF manuals out there sans bookmarks. Disgraceful!  See my article about “Tightship Associates” for more details on what bookmarks can really mean in simple productivity terms.

The lack of Bookmarks is a serious drag on the economy, dang it!  :-)

4)  Once bookmarked, ENSURE that bookmarks are visible to the user when the file is opened.  A trivial point?  Not at all… our testing has shown that only 20% of files out there with bookmarks actually DISPLAY the bookmarks when the PDF is opened for viewing.  It’s a simple fix, people.  File >> Properties >> Initial View; take it from there.

5) Consider little touches like a ”Print this section” button.  It’s easy functionality to add using Acrobat JavaScript, and it’s just one of the many ways you can use simple PDF tricks to provide a rich and flexible end-user experience that can precisely accommodate real-world usage.

An example:  We might add “print this section” buttons to a manual, but for a section that includes a form, perhaps we do something different.  Here, we might add a special buttons to the form that print JUST the form.  Then, we change the section-print button to skip over the form.  Why?  Why not?  It’s EXACTLY the sort of thing end-users determine that they want and need want.  That’s up to them, we just build it.  And so can you.

2 Responses to “Using PDF for Help files”

  1. GloriaMc Says:

    Duff,
    Thank you very much for this great information. It will be very helpful as we plot our future.

    I’d like to go back to the article that sparked the whole thing for a minute - your review of the Adobe Help. You said “ACROHELP had become a bit ridiculous, itself a bloated demonstration of why a PDF is NOT always the right format for all content and all contexts…” Granted that PDF was behemoth (700+ pages avail. in a single scroll), but it did have many of the qualities you mention above. Plz comment a bit more on what about the PDF Help you found so abhorrent.

    Thanks again for pursuing this topic on my behalf. I really appreciate it.

    Regards,
    –Gloria Mc

  2. duffjohnson Says:

    You are welcome. To answer your question, IMHO, the Acrobat 7 ACROHELP.PDF includes several errors. Here’s what offends me the most:

    ++ Physical page-size is (believe it or now) determined by the length of the subject, with a minimum size of US letter, and a maximum of way, way too long (I forget, but over 60 inches).

    Theoretically, this allows the user to scroll through a single issue without turning a page. In practice, it prints very poorly.

    ++ There are no page numbers, and due to the variable page-lengths, page numbers are actually impossible in this design context.

    ++ There is no option for page vs. screen-oriented viewing

    ++ Bookmark levels are organized and structured poorly - the bookmark hierarchy is not used effectively.

    ++ Toolbars should be (IMHO) hidden.

    ++ There are no “print this section” buttons, or any other assisting buttons.

    It’s not so much that the ACROHELP.PDF is super-awful (although the variable page length issue is pretty serious). Rather, it SHOULD be a “perfect” PDF, an exemplar of its kind. Instead, it’s not even close.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.